Monday, November 12, 2012

11/12 Comparing and Contrasting Teachers, 2nd Paper Rough Draft


Comparing and Contrasting Teachers

Most students walk from class to class in that familiar haze of the normal school day. And most Teacher’s contribute to that “haze” with their boring same old teachings we as students hear every day of the year, copy the notes, write definitions for the homework etc. But there are a slight few, the Educators who go well above and beyond the normal requirements. Those whose goal is to inspire the students to live beyond societies, and their own ideals. Teachers are some are the most influential people as you grow up and develop. The great teachers are mentors truly inspire their students, because they respect the profound privilege they possess molding the minds of the future.

High-school is a very difficult time for students. It’s a true time for development, a time where a student’s mind can be molded for the future. I for one did not always put my best effort into my schoolwork. My junior year I had an English teacher, Mr. McCormick. He was strict but treated all of us as adults. He did not require the overuse of guidelines when writing our essays, he gave us a lot of creative freedom. I remember one time I had a paper due on a reading called “Tom Green and the Devil”. Unfortunately, I did not always turn my assignments in on time, and this instance was no different. I turned the paper in a week late, once Mr. McCormick finished reading it, he asked me “Who helped you write this?” He told me I was an amazing writer and he knew I was not putting my full effort, had I turned the paper in on time I would have gotten an “A”.  Mr. McCormick was one of those teachers you could tell loved his job. He was passionate about English and reading books, they lined all the shelves in his classroom. You couldn’t help but catch that enthusiasm to enjoy reading. He brought me back into my love of books, my addiction to the written word. And for that I will be forever grateful.

Mr. Keating from the “Dead Poets Society” is the kind of teacher I wish I had more often in school. He was a man who did not adhere to the “norm”.  He said “No matter what anybody tells you words and ideas can change the world.” He wanted his boys to question what they are told to be, to find themselves and what they want to do in the world. Teaching at the Welton Preparatory School in 1949 was a time where students did not questions their roles in life, everything was decided for them by that point.  He told his boys “Carpi Diem, Make your lives extraordinary boys.”  Mr. Keating knew just how much potential each of his students had, he simply wanted to push them towards it. He wanted them to really make something of themselves and make a difference in this world. Mr. Keating taught his boys with such a passion, that it was contagious. His boys caught his passion for poetry and how they could use it in all aspects of their lives. He didn’t want them to grow up and one day realizes they missed out on something great, something that really mattered to them.  He told them "Boys, you must strive to find your own voice. Because the longer you wait to begin, the less likely you are to find it at all. Thoreau said, "Most men lead lives of quiet desperation." Don't be resigned to that. Break out! "

Teachers should always try and provoke the students to ask questions, let the class be interesting and more challenging. Mr. McCormick made his classes very interesting every day. He even re-arranged his classroom with half the desks on one side of the room and half on the other so that we could debate different topics for class.  There were times when the entire class was just us, the students going back and forth with different opinions, Mr. McCormick chiming in leading us in one directions or another. I think I learned more those days than all the times I spent copying down definitions or notes from an overhead projector put together.  Challenging us as students to think bigger than just our English class, giving us skills that in that moment we no idea we would need as we grew up and became adults.

The worst thing a teacher can do is not care about what they are teaching their students.  We have all had a teacher before who did not care, one who just showed up to work everyday collect their paycheck and hand out total nonsense assignments.  I don’t believe that most do it on purpose, I think they sometimes lose their “will” to teach and when that time does come it should be time to stop teaching.  The great teachers never lose their will to teach, they keep pushing because they know what they are doing matters, their influence over these kids matters.  In the Dead Poets Society we see when the head master takes over Mr. Keating’s class that he does not have the passion Mr. Keating does. He simply tells the boys to take out their books and read out loud.  We also saw this in “Stand and Deliver” when the other teachers say that the students are too behind to even matter. Mr. Escalante, and very good teacher, tells them that “The students will rise to your level of expectation”.  He knew that if he applied himself to do the very best for his students, then they would do the best for him.

If you think back on all your years of school and all of your teachers, who stands out? The great teachers you remember for the amazing lessons they taught you, the ones you keep with you always. It was the ones whose passion and excitement for what they taught made you want to learn more and do better in your classes. Do you remember the other teachers? Every other teacher I had who did the bare minimum is a blur for me. I remember some of the really bad teachers, only because they were so terrible I actually felt cheated from my education. But I will always remember my great teachers, my mentors. They are amazing people and deserve so much gratitude for what they did for me, as Mr. Keating and Mr. Escalante did for their students. Education is something that can never be taken away from you by anyone, it should be cherished.

 

No comments:

Post a Comment