Let me start with a very important difference I saw in these films. Both of these movies take place during a different era. The Dead Poet's Society is set in 1949, That was back in a time that children did what they were told and when they were told by their parents. Stand and Deliver was set in the 1980s, a time famous for rebellion (from what I have been told by my parents). These eras should be taken into account while watching these films for some of the obvious differences in them.
The Welton, or "Helton" school as the students affectionately refer to it, is clearly very different from the school that Mr. Escalante taught at. Welton, is an upper class all boys preparatory school where only the very wealthy attend and then go on to Ivy League schools. Mr. Escalante's school was in a lower class ethic neighborhood with barely enough funds to keep the school open. Some may immediately say that Welton is better than the school from Stand and Deliver. I don't know for sure that is true. I think both schools hold the students back in different ways, it is the teachers that make the difference, the individual who puts forth the effort.
Mr. Keating and Mr. Escalante are very similar. Though they come from very different backgrounds, they both have great teaching methods. They use humor to teach their students, and really interact with them. Mr. Escalante focuses more on educating the core subject of Math to a higher degree of learning. While Mr. Keating is focusing on poetry, one of the Arts. He says that poetry can help you through your entire life, because "the human race is full of passion". I think Mr. Keating is making boys into men. Helping them learn to think for themselves. Because back in the 1950s it was a time of family and living up to their expectations doing what they wanted you to do and only that. So far, my favorite quote describes Mr. Keating's reason for wanting the boys to become self-thinking individuals, "Make your lives extraordinary Boys". After hearing this and his explanation for the importance of poetry to another teacher I thought back to the Sir Ken Robinson video. Where he says "Education kills Creativity" and that "Creativity is equal to literacy in importance". That is what Mr. Keating believes, and that his boys need creativity/passion/extraordinary, whatever you want to call it, in their lives to succeed.
I really like both of these teachers, and I think their motives may be different as to what they are doing for their students. But they are both amazing teachers.
Tuesday, October 30, 2012
Mr. Escalante Vs. Mr. MacFarland
Mr. MacFarland sounds a lot like Mr. Escalante was depicted in the film. I picture him as a messy Scottish redheaded type of English teacher. As apposed to Mr. Escalante's sometimes disheveled appearance. Though both teachers could careless about what they looked like and more about their students actually learning. The phrase from the reading "The troublemaker would look foolish rather than daring", immediately made me think back to the film when the bad kids would try to intimidate and provoke Mr. Escalante. And in turn would make the kids look ridiculous instead of letting them get to him and throw him off what he was trying to teach. Exactly the same thing was described in the story.
Both Mr. MacFarland and Mr. Escalante are trying to hold their students to a higher level of learning than to what just the school expects. Mr. Escalante's statement "the students will rise to your expectations" is a perfect example of this. They both seem to really inspire their students to learn and educate themselves far beyond their own expectations.
I really took to the fact that Mr. MacFarland called the college he graduated from to get Mike Rose into college and wrote him an outstanding letter of recommendation. Because I had a teacher that did the exact same thing for me at one point, the letter of recommendation he wrote me was for the college he graduated from as well.
I believe both of these teachers are amazing and go far and beyond what normal teachers do when it comes to their students!
Both Mr. MacFarland and Mr. Escalante are trying to hold their students to a higher level of learning than to what just the school expects. Mr. Escalante's statement "the students will rise to your expectations" is a perfect example of this. They both seem to really inspire their students to learn and educate themselves far beyond their own expectations.
I really took to the fact that Mr. MacFarland called the college he graduated from to get Mike Rose into college and wrote him an outstanding letter of recommendation. Because I had a teacher that did the exact same thing for me at one point, the letter of recommendation he wrote me was for the college he graduated from as well.
I believe both of these teachers are amazing and go far and beyond what normal teachers do when it comes to their students!
Thursday, October 25, 2012
Stand and Deliver Part 1
At first Mr. Escalante comes across as a very shy man who was put in way over his head. He quickly takes control of his class. The class seems to take to him very fast and starts participating and learning. He uses humor and terms the students can understand and relate to. Mr Escalante devotes so much of his time to his students, sacrifying his personnel life. I found it interesting that he gave up his high paying job with the computer company to become a teacher. I remember watching this movie in highschool and how boring I thought it was, I actually was not looking forward to being forced to watch this again. However, now as an adult i find the dynamic of the student/teacher relationship very interesting and am really enjoying the movie. One of the things asked after the first part of the video at the end of class was how Audre Lord's teachers compare to Mr. Escalante? Most of the students said things like "they are both stricked". After class was over i was thinking, there is no comparasion, they are polar opposites. Mr. Escalante takes the time to teach his students and he expects them to "rise to his expectation". Audre's teachers did not teach! They went by the set standard by the school and actually punished any student who tried to go above and beyond, therefore holding the child back instead of increasing their expectations as Mr. Escalante does.
Tuesday, October 23, 2012
Audre Lord Essay
Audre did an amazing job at describing
her teachers, though she did not remember exactly what they looked like just
from her memories and what they smelled or sounded like. I was appalled while reading how ignorant her
teachers seemed. The nun should have figured out that she could not recognize
her numbers and that was why she was always lost during class. The public
school teacher showed how standardized she wanted her class, and not to let the
smart child write her entire name instead of just a letter. I did love how the
librarian who took the time to read her a story seemed the only good teacher
Audre had. Anyone who has worked with any type of special needs child knows
they all want to learn, you just need to take your time and find out what way
works best for teaching them. Overall in the essay, though the girl could not
see well, her memories provide vivid illustrations of what she remembers of her
teachers. To me, the two actual teachers she had seemed like the villains of
the story and the descriptions she gave made me really dislike the teachers
entirely. Even her mother seemed like a villain at some points, though in
others she shows how her mother took the time to teach her the alphabet and how
to read and write her name. But out of all the teachers, the librarian was my
favorite, even though she wasn’t in the story that much, she clearly states
that the librarian saved her life.
What makes a Good Teacher? (To Me)
I think the thing I value most in a teacher is when they treat their students like adults instead of children that they get paid very well to babysit. Teachers should be passionate about what they teach and not afraid to inspire their students. I hate when a teacher just teaches the subject they are assigned, ignore all questions, or never allow any creative thinking in their classroom, yet preach “Critical Thinking” all day in their class. Almost any subject taught can bring up different viewpoints that can result in in depth discussions in the class. There are some teachers I have had or have now that refuse to let a student question anything they say, it’s almost like a “God Complex” in way that they are the teachers therefore they cannot possibly be wrong. I enjoy when teachers let us as students participate in class where we can ask questions, challenge the teacher in a way. It makes me learn more if that makes sense. Teachers should take the time to really help the students who want to learn. Take a little extra time to answer questions more in depth when a student who is really trying to understand a concept but it is just out of their grasp, it’s not that the student doesn’t care, just sometimes it needs to be explained in a different way for them to fully understand it. Also I think it is important for a teacher to keep things interesting. Those are just a few things I value in teachers.
Brainstorming for my 2nd Paper
I know
this paper will be a compare and contrast of Teachers paper. Thinking back on
some of the greatest teachers I have had, the ones that made an impact as great
teachers are the ones I actually remember. The three teachers I remember the
most were, My English teacher from 11th grade Mr. McCormick, my
history teacher from 10th grade Mrs. Provo, and my Astronomy teacher
from 12th grade, Mr. Regan. I
remember in 10th grade my goal was to make straight A’s in school,
Mrs. Provo was my history teacher and I remember my last final for 1st
semester was in her class, I studied so hard and did as much as I could and I got
an A in her class. She was so proud of me and gave me so much credit for all
the work I did. Ever year after I would see her in the hallway and she would
always ask me and actually get on me to make sure I was still doing my best in
all my classes. In 11th grade I was working a lot and while English was
always my favorite and strongest subject I found myself falling behind. I
remember turning in a paper late, but Mr. McCormick wrote on my paper “Who helped
you write this?”, He knew I wasn’t doing my work to my full potential and was
impressed when I turned in that paper. He said I would have gotten an A had it
been turned in on time. He also wrote me an amazing recommendation letter for
college. Unfortunately after Senior year Mr. McCormick disappeared, he just did
not show up for work, and to this day no one knows what happened to him. In 12th
grade I had Mr. Regan for Astronomy, my favorite class, I had a problem waking
up on time for school due to my work hours and he always waited until the last
moment of class to take attendance just for me, and always stayed late after
school to let me make up my classwork, tests and hours I needed to graduate on
time. We also had night classes on the football field for extra credit to
actually study the stars. He put in a lot of effort to make our class fun and
educational. I know I will want to put in a little bit of these teachers
examples for my paper because they really meant so much to me.
Sir Ken Robinson Video Lecture
I found Sir Robinson’s lecture very entertaining and
informative. I think had he not had humor in his speech I wouldn’t have been
able to pay as much attention as I did. Most lectures are very dry and slow,
his was the opposite. He says things such as “I believe everyone’s education
background is interesting”, “Creativity is equal to literacy in importance”,
and “children are talented and we squander them”. All of these statements
really resonated with me. To squander children’s talent is a crime, I love how
he told the story of the ballerina who these days would have just been put on
medication for ADHD instead of her doctor showing her mother that she was a
dancer. And the world would have missed out on her talent, and her immense
contributions to the arts. I do agree with him that creativity is just as
important as literacy. If people did not have creativity then we would be
missing out on so much in this world, people would not invent things, would not
write amazing books and stories, etc. I
really loved the statement where he says “if you are always prepared to be
wrong then you will never take a chance”. Sometimes is better to try and be
proven wrong then to never try at all, in all aspects of your life.
Wednesday, October 17, 2012
Education Narrative 10/17/12 Final Draft
Meagan
Caten
English
101
A
Mother’s Lessons For Life
An
Education Narrative
I have always
believed that the most important form of education you can receive is from your
own life experiences and that which is taught to you from your parents. “Part
of the reason [motherly advice] bugs us as daughters is because our mothers are
so powerful in our lives. They loom like giants. The reason mothers keep at it
is because they're so powerless. They cannot get you to do what is so obvious
to them you should do.” - Deborah Tannen. The New York Times bestselling author
and professor of linguistics at Georgetown University in Washington, D.C. could
not have said anything more true. My own
mother tried to instill the best values and life lessons she could in me while
I was growing up. And though I was challenging and hard headed at times, as any
teenage girl can be, to my complete shock and awe they actually stuck. The
three life lessons that she burned into my subconscious are; “Figure it out for
yourself”, “Can’t never could do anything”, and “Just think how good it will
feel when it stops hurting”.
Because I was a
very shy child growing up I had some problems with doing things on my own. I remember resenting my Mom every time she
would not help me, for instance when I hit a curb with my car and blew out two
tires and bent the rims. I knew nothing about cars, but “Figure it out for yourself”
was the only help I got. I didn’t know
where to start so she pointed me in the right direction and sent me out on my
own to do what needed to be done. It took a long time and a lot of arguments but
after all was said and done I really felt like I had accomplished something,
fixing my car on my own was the first instance where I remember feeling truly
independent. As you can see this was
around a time in my life when I needed to become more independent and therefore
more responsible for myself and my actions. She needed me to be accountable for
my own actions. Now as an adult I have no problem going somewhere or calling
many different people when I have something I do not understand, like enrolling
for this semester of college. Had I still had those shy tendencies I really
believe that I would never have gotten enrolled. Instead I showed up at the
Veterans Affairs office asking as many questions as possible to understand
every aspect of what I needed to do. I was very honest in the fact that I had
no idea what I was doing and most everyone I spoke with was more than happy to
point me in the right direction. The most recent instance I can remember
thinking back to this lesson is when our septic tank went out in our house after
6:00 PM we figured out that something was wrong. Talk about some disgusting
stuff! I instantly went into “How can I
figure this out mode?” I got on the phone and called our septic maintenance
guy, Hercules, who is amazing and told him what was going on. He was at our
house by 7 pm and told us what needed to be done. Hercules had told me to call
a pump service and electrician. The next morning I had everything set up and
the septic pump system was fixed by the following day. Again that sense of
pride and accomplishment I had was indescribable, but doing something on my own
and fixing the problem in such little time really meant something to me. So if you are ever stuck “Figure it out for
yourself” , make those phone calls or show up and start asking questions,
otherwise you will never find out what it is you need to do to fix a
situation.
Now I know that
this phrase “Can’t never could do anything” isn’t considered proper English.
But these words have been said repeatedly growing up. Saying “I can’t” do
something, be someone etc. is limiting yourself and your potential. This lesson
is one my mother wanted to guarantee she had etched in my mind for the rest of
my life. Before I left home for boot camp in the US Navy I remember being
terrified of what I was getting myself into. Terrified of the unknown factors I
was about to face for at least the next five years of my life. I remember
sitting in my mother’s office at work one day having a total mental breakdown
telling her “What if I can’t do this? What if I just can’t” and she simply said
“Can’t never could do anything Meagan”. I had heard it over and over again as I
grew up and it always seemed like one of those annoying phrases your parents
tell you when they cannot think of anything better to say such as “Because I
said so”. This was not the case, I remember sitting there stunned and she told
me that if I keep saying “I can’t” then I simply never would. I will hold
myself back and miss out on so much on life.
A month later I was in boot camp, every time I was tired or frustrated
or getting yelled at I would remember “Can’t never could do anything” and I
would force myself to keep pushing, keep going
and not give up just because I thought I couldn’t do it. I could do it, I
did do it, and it was by far the best thing I have ever done. And the only
person who could have taken that away from me was myself.
“Just think how
good it’s going to feel when it stops hurting.” Those were the words I remember
hearing when I was little and feeling sick or crying over a skinned knee. They
were always said with love and comfort by my mother. What I didn’t know then is this could be
applied to real life. We have all had our hearts broken at one point or another
in life; it may have been the loss of a relationship, grief over the passing of
a friend or loved one, loss of a job etc. And in that moment when we are
feeling utterly lost as if this immense pain we are feeling will never heal,
never go away, and will leaving a hole in our soul. But after time that pain
fades, you never forget the pain but it does fade and eventually you heal. To
“Just think how good it’s going to feel when it stops hurting” is not to tell
you do not feel the pain, to not grieve for your loss, but remember that it
will stop. This is not the end all be all, you will survive and just look
forward to that moment when you can smile again. I have lost friends and what keeps me going
are these words “Just think how good it’s going to feel when it stops
hurting”. I find so much comfort in
these words that it truly does help.
You can have all
the formal education in the world, but common sense is priceless. That’s what
all of these life lessons I was given boil down to. I have had a lot of
military and civilian education in my life, but the lessons I value most are
those I was taught by my mother, the words that keep me going, keep me focused.
And that is something you can never learn in a formal education system. Be independent, “Figure it out for yourself”.
Only you can hold yourself back, “Can’t never could do anything”. And pain is
only in the moment and lets you know that you are alive, “Just think how good
it’s going to feel when it stops hurting”.
Saturday, October 13, 2012
Education Narrative (Very) Rough Draft
Education Narrative Outline
INTRODUCTION:
“Part of the reason [motherly
advice] bugs us as daughters is because our mothers are so powerful in our
lives. They loom like giants. The reason mothers keep at it is because they're
so powerless. They cannot get you to do what is so obvious to them you should
do.” - Deborah Tannen. The New York Times bestselling author and professor of
linguistics at Georgetown University in Washington, D.C. could not have said
anything more true. My own mother tried
to instill the best values and life lessons she could in me while I was growing
up. And though I was challenging at times, as any teenage girl can be, to my
complete shock and awe they actually stuck. The three life lessons that she
burned into my subconscious are; “Figure it out for yourself”, “Can’t never could
do anything”, and “Just think how good it will feel when it stops
hurting”. These may sound strange to
some, but growing up hearing these repeatedly they start to make sense and
apply to everyday life.
PARAGRAPH ONE- FIGURE IT OUT FOR
YOURSELF:
Because I was a very shy child growing up I had some
problems with doing things on my own. When it came time to get my driver’s
license I kept asking my mother to get me into a driver’s education program to
get my permit. Her response, “Figure it
out for yourself!” She was not trying to be mean or not interested in helping
me she just wanted me to be independent and find the school myself and make the
nessasary phone calls to get myself into a class. I remember resenting her every
time she would not help me, for instance when I hit a curb with my car and blew
out two tires and bent the rims. I knew nothing about cars, but “Figure it out
for yourself” was the only help I really got. I didn’t know where to start so she pointed me
in the right direction that I needed to order the tires online because it was
probably cheaper and find a wheel and tire store that would fix the bent tire
rims. It took me a long time and a lot of fighting but afterwards I really felt
like I had accomplished something, fixing my car on my own was a big accomplishment
for me. The worst situation I remember I was driving my mom’s car to work one
day and got my first ticket, expired registration. It was not my car therefore I
thought she should be the one to help me with the ticket. I missed the arranged court day by one day,
then she told me the next day to get up and get myself to the courthouse,
explain that I missed the date by one day and beg them as to what I need to do
next. I went, very unhappy, but I went. The lady at the counter was actually
very nice to me, told me it was ok and that it happens all of the time, all I needed
to do was show proof of the new registration and pay a small fine. Looking back on these few instances I remember
being so angry with my mom for not helping me. But as you can see they were all
around a time when I needed to become more independent and therefore more responsible
for myself and my actions. Now as an
adult I have no problem going somewhere or calling many different people when I
have something I do not know how to do, like enrolling for this semester of
college. Had I still had those shy tendencies I really believe that I would
never have gotten enrolled. Instead I showed up at the Veterans Affairs office
asking as many questions as possible to understand every aspect of what I needed
to do. I was very honest that I had no idea what I was doing and most everyone I
spoke with was more than happy to point me in the right direction. The best
example I can remember thinking back to this lesson is when our septic tank
went out in our house around 6pm we figured out that it was close to over
flowing. Talk about some disgusting stuff! I instantly went into “How can I figure this
out mode?” I got on the phone and called our septic maintenance guy, Hercules,
who is amazing and gave told him what was going on. He was at our house by 7 pm
and told us what needed to be done. Hercules had told me to call a pump service
and electrian. The next morning I had everything set up and the septic pump was
fixed by the following day. Again that sense of pride and accomplishment I had
was indescribable, but doing something on your own and fixing the problem in
such little time really meant something to me. So if you are ever stuck “Figure it out for
yourself” , make those phone calls or show up and start asking questions,
otherwise you will never find out what it is you need to do to fix a
situation.
PARAGRAPH TWO- CANT NEVER COULD
DO ANYTHING:
Now I know that this phrase “Can’t never could do anything” isn’t
considered proper English. But the words have stuck with me since I was a
child. Saying “I can’t” do something, be someone etc. is limiting yourself and
your potential. This lesson is one my mother wanted to make sure she had etched
in my mind for the rest of my life. Before I left home for bootcamp in the US
Navy I remember being terrified of what I was getting myself into. Terrified of
the unknown factors I was about to face for at least the next five years of my
life. I remember sitting in my mother’s office at work one day having a total
mental breakdown telling her “What if I can’t do this? What if I just can’t”
and she simply said “Can’t never could do anything Meagan”. I had heard it over
and over again growing up and it always seemed like one of those annoying
phrases your parents tell you when they cannot think of anything better to say
such as “Because I said so”. This was not the case, I remember sitting there
stunned and she told me that if I keep saying “I can’t” then I simply never
will. I will hold myself back and miss out on so much on life. A month later I was in bootcamp, every time I
was tired or frustrated or getting yelled at I would remember “Can’t never
could do anything” and I would force myself to keep pushing, keep going and not give up because I thought I couldn’t do
it.
PARAGRAPH THREE- JUST THINK HOW
GOOD ITS GOING TO FEEL WHEN IT STOPS HURTING:
“Just think how good it’s going to feel when it stops
hurting.” Those were the words I remember hearing when I was little and feeling
sick or crying over a skinned knee. They were always said with love and comfort
from my mother. What I didn’t know then
is this could be applied to real life. We have all had our hearts broken at one
point or another in life, it may have been the loss of a relationship, grief
over the passing of a friend or loved one, loss of a job etc. And in that
moment when we are feeling utterly lost as if this immense pain we are feeling
will never heal, never go away, and will leaving a hole in our soul. But
depending on the situation, after time that pain fades, you never forget the
pain but it does fade and eventually you heal. To “Just think how good it’s
going to feel when it stops hurting” is not to tell you do not feel the pain,
to not grieve for your loss, but remember that it will stop. This is not the end
all be all, you will survive and just look forward to that moment when you can
smile again. I have lost friends and
have had major painful surgery in my life, and what keeps me going are these
words “Just think how good it’s going to feel when it stops hurting”. I find so much comfort in these words that it
truly does help.
CONCLUSION:
You can have all the formal education in the world, but
common sense is priceless. That’s what all of these life lessons I was taught
boil down to. I have had a lot of military and civilian education in my life,
but the lessons I value most are those I was taught by my mother, the words
that keep me going, keep me focused. And that is something you can never learn
in a formal education system. Be
independent, “Figure it out for yourself”. Only you can hold yourself back, “Can’t
never could do anything”. And pain is only in the moment and lets you know that
you are alive, “Just think how good it’s going to feel when it stops hurting”.
QUOTES:
Part of the reason [motherly advice] bugs us as daughters is
because our mothers are so powerful in our lives. They loom like giants. The
reason mothers keep at it is because they're so powerless. They cannot get you
to do what is so obvious to them you should do.
- Deborah Tannen
WORK CITED INFO:
Tannen, Deborah. “Wisdom Quotes.” Wisdomquotes.com . Web. 09
October 2012.
Thursday, October 11, 2012
Introduction to Education Narrative
“Part of the reason [motherly
advice] bugs us as daughters is because our mothers are so powerful in our
lives. They loom like giants. The reason mothers keep at it is because they're
so powerless. They cannot get you to do what is so obvious to them you should
do.” - Deborah Tannen. The New York Times bestselling author and professor of
linguistics at Georgetown University in Washington, D.C. could not have said
anything more true. My own mother tried
to instill the best values and life lessons she could in me while I was growing
up. And though I was challenging at times, as any teenage girl can be, to my
complete shock and awe they actually stuck. The three life lessons that she burned
into my subconscious are; “Figure it out for yourself”, “Can’t never could do
anything”, and “Just think how good it will feel when it stops hurting”. These may sound strange to some, but it was
what I was grew up hearing, and the more you hear them over and over again the
more they start to make sense.
The Differences and Similarities in the 3 Writing Styles of Rose, Franklin and X
Having now read and wrote about the 3 different writings for
class I can pinpoint key differences and similarities between the narratives
and styles of writing. Malcolm X’s and Mike Rose’s narratives seemed more
informal in the way they were written. Benjamin Franklin’s narrative on the
other hand seemed a lot more formal, but now looking at it again, I think his
could be considered informal as well. He just had a different way of speaking
back in that era, so it came off as a more formal type of writing. In both Franklin and X’s narratives you could
tell they both had a passion for what they were learning, while Rose’s
narrative was more on his lack of passion for learning growing up due to his circumstance
of being placed in the wrong class. While Malcolm’s narrative had a better
flow, Rose and Franklin’s narrative had a lot of details, giving more of a back
story to the point they were each trying to make. Franklin’s tone seemed to stay on a more
positive tone. Rose’s tone seemed to be more negative towards education. And X’s
would bounce back in forth between the two with being positive about learning
to read and negative about other parts of his story.
Tuesday, October 9, 2012
My Favorite of the 3 Readings for Class
I Just Wanna Be
Average, By Mike Rose
I feel like I really connected more with Mike Rose’s story.
His way of writing has very good descriptive qualities, really giving depth to
the story and the characters in the story. He painted a very vivid picture of
how the Voc. Ed. was in southern LA. The
last two paragraphs really resonated with me the most. How he said “Ken Harvey
was gasping for air.” referring to him saying “I just wanna be average”. Meaning if you don’t fit into what society feels
is the “norm” then you don’t matter and that can be a very suffocating thought
to process. The truth is no one really fits the “norm”, is a stupid stigma that
started somewhere and everyone just accepts it. Everyone is different and so
everyone should be able to have the same opportunities as the “elite” or “privileged”
students. His entire story is about the
lacking of education in his school. It’s actually sad that schools like this
were out there and probably still out there. There was a vocational program at
my high school , I didn’t know that much about it except the students took
classes only half of the school day and then the other half they went to
whatever their job was. I just really enjoyed this story much better than the
other two we read.
Writing Development, What Helps Me
Writing Development Strategies
I have
always enjoyed writing. English has always been my favorite subject. I have a
few different methods I have used in the past to help me with my writing. Most
of the time, I would just put pen to paper and start writing. If it didn’t really
make sense I would just keep going, keep writing, until I got everything out
that I wanted to say and that would be my first draft. I would then print it
out and go over it, marking the entire page up with how I wanted to move
certain things around, switch out words and different things like that. It was
a messy and chaotic strategy but it really worked for me when I needed to
overcome writers block. When I didn’t have
a case of writers block I was really into outlining. Which is basically the
opposite of my other strategy I know, but when I am focused I am very
organized. I would outline each paragraph, with each beginning and ending or
transitioning sentence I wanted to use. I would insert any quotes or examples
from texts that I was going to use. And
slowly but surely I would end up with an almost complete paper in front of me
ready to be typed up and finished. So from one extreme to another i could always eventually use one or the other to produce a great paper.
"I just wanna be average" Questions
“I Just Wanna Be Average”
Questions:
1)
Describe Rose’s Life
in Voc. Ed. What were his teachers like? Have you ever experienced teachers
like these?
To have been placed in Voc. Ed. by
accident, Rose explains it as a place where the “bottom of the barrel” kids in
school were sent. The school does not expect anything out of them, therefore
did not waste any time or effort on them.
His teachers probably wanted to be anywhere
but where they were. I mean who wants to teach kids who the school deems are
not worth teaching right? (Please note my sarcasm.) His teachers in my honest
opinion sound like a disgrace.
I have really only had one teacher that
sounds as bad as he describes his. My freshman year in high school I had a French
teacher who sounds a lot like his Spanish teacher. She was Muslim, and a very
quiet woman. She never could get control of the classroom which consisted of 9th-12th
graders. I always kind of felt bad for her. I think it was because of her lack of
authority that she could not get control of us, and in turn did not teach us.
2)
What did Voc. Ed. do
to Rose and his fellow students? How did it affect them intellectually,
emotionally, and socially? Why was it subsequently so hard for Rose to catch up
in math?
I think Voc. Ed. steered their
lives towards more mediocre and blue collar jobs and futures. It sounds like
they were never challenged to rise to their potentials. Intellectually, they
were not challenged or even stimulated in any kind of educational way.
Emotionally, their self-worth was probably not very high, as the one kid stated
he just wanted to be average. Socially, I really think that all that they went
thru in Voc. Ed. together they formed strong bonds and stuck together. On the opposite
side of that, as they grew older, their social norms were probably very
different from those who went thru normal high-school. Math is a hard subject
to keep up on if you are not constantly using it. He might have learned things
differently in Italy versus the state’s education system. But his teachers
probably thought if he was never going to understand or use his education then
why bother teaching them at all.
3)
Why is high school
so disorienting to students like Ken Harvey? How does he cope with it? What
other strategies do students use to cope with the pressures and judgments they
encounter in school?
Ken had one thing in life that had already
completely drawn him in, cars. He seemed to be a keep to himself kind of
person, so high school with all the different back grounds and personalities
you encounter can be very scary and disorienting. He seems to cope with it by
not adding attention to himself by being just “average”. Most students join whatever group they seem
to fall into best, for ex; jocks, nerds, artsy, gothic, country, etc. And if
they do not fall into a group they become quiet and keep to themselves.
4)
Rose explains in
paragraph 16. That high school can be a “tremendously disorienting place.”
What, if anything do you find disorienting about college? What steps can
students take to lessen the feelings or disorientation?
I find college pretty disorienting.
I don’t know in most of my classes how I am doing grades wise. But the best way
I have learned to figure out this whole college thing is to ask questions. I
have one teacher this quarter who does nothing but copy and paste text from the
book and whatever “she thinks is more important than the book” onto a power
point and then reads verbatim what is on the power point, that is each of our 2
hour class. Her tests have nothing from the review words she has us study. But
to counter her lack of teaching, I simply read and teach the subject to myself.
I do extra reviews, work, online research to have a better understanding of the
subject.
5)
How does your
experience of education compare (or contrast, or both) to Mike Rose’s?
I had kind of the same beginning in my
education that Rose did, set in class way below my abilities and not challenge
what so ever. After having my class
level situation fixed, I had a bit of a rebellion phase freshman year in high
school, almost being held back a year. But instead of letting myself get
behind, I buckled down and showed people they were wrong about me and that I could
do anything I put my mind to. That is one of my favorite things in the whole
world, proving people wrong when they think the worst of me.
Saturday, October 6, 2012
Classification for Education Narrative Paper
I am planning on writing about the 3 main life lessons passed down to me from my Mom. It wasn't formal education, but has helped me more than anything I have yet to learn in school really. Lesson 1, "Figure it out for yourself". Anytime there was something i needed to do, ie. Getting my drivers license, fixing my car, getting a job, joining the navy, etc. I would always ask my mother for help, and usually she would say "Well, what have you done to try and do this yourself?". She would usually steer me in the right direction of what to do, but it was up to me to make the calls and ask the questions I needed to. I think that was by far the most important lesson she ever taught me. Lesson 2, "Can't never could to anything". Yes a very Southern phrase, but as soon as the words " I can't!" came out of my mouth, those were the next to come out of hers. Later in life, anytime I catch myself saying that or someone else saying that, I remember my Moms words and remind myself that if I make myself believe that I cannot do something then i never will do it. Lesson 3, "Just think how good it's going to feel when it stops hurting". This is what she said anytime we were little and crying to calm us down and make us see it really wasn't all that bad in the first place. Now as an adult I think back on this one anytime I am sad or have something going wrong in my life. I remember that eventually the hurt will stop, the hurt always fades over time. Classification was clearly my choice for this pre-writing exercise because it was simple to classify these into the three life lessons from my Mother.
Thursday, October 4, 2012
10/04/12 Benjamin Franklin VS Malcolm X's Stories
While Mr. Franklin's essay takes a little more adjusting to his way of speaking for that era, it was a very good representation of that time. I loved and laughed at the part where his father told him, he "should break away and get to sea" because that is exactly what my mother told me when i didnt know what do for school.
I think the writings are similar because both men were self educated by reading whatever they could get their hands on. Both had a different way of speaking which was appropriate for their era. They both valued their education they recieved from reading as much as they could.
The differences I noticed in the writings were Mr. Franklin went to school to get a least a start to his education while Mr. X had to start from nothing while in prison. Clearly one of one of the biggest differences i noticed was Benjamin Franklin was one of America's founding fathers and did amazing things to further our country. While Mr. X was a leader of a sort of Political party that was more geared to negativness and segregation in our country.
I think the writings are similar because both men were self educated by reading whatever they could get their hands on. Both had a different way of speaking which was appropriate for their era. They both valued their education they recieved from reading as much as they could.
The differences I noticed in the writings were Mr. Franklin went to school to get a least a start to his education while Mr. X had to start from nothing while in prison. Clearly one of one of the biggest differences i noticed was Benjamin Franklin was one of America's founding fathers and did amazing things to further our country. While Mr. X was a leader of a sort of Political party that was more geared to negativness and segregation in our country.
Wednesday, October 3, 2012
10/03/12 Past pre-writing that worked for me
Writing Simplified: Pre-Writing
Pre-Writing is super important to me. When writing a paper I
always have tons of idea floating around in my head that I want to include in
the paper. The techniques I have used in the past the most were usually “Listing”
and “Mapping” or a combination of the two. Listing is great for finding parts
of the subject that you really want to focus on the most for the different
paragraphs in the essay or writing. Mapping is a way to work on your papers
flow. I get frustrated when I know I have a great paper in my mind, but can’t
get the flow right. So I will write down how I want the paper to go and certain
connecting phrases or sentences that I know I will want to include in the paper
to bring the whole thing together in a way that makes sense. After I have
written a paper I usually have a friend or family member proofread it for me to
point out anything that doesn’t seem right or any spelling grammar issues. (I tend
to go so fast writing that I miss simple things). The book has some other techniques to I am
going to try to plan out my papers this quarter.
10/03/12 "Learning to Read"
Malcolm X’s “Learning to Read”
I found Malcolm X’s story very interesting. I enjoyed how he
described discovering new words and how he really let the emotions he felt
towards reading and learning come through in his story. I think his story gave a great example of a
Narrative paper, even more so than “how I learned to program computers”. He
draws you into the story by not holding back on any of the emotions he felt. I couldn’t
imagine learning to read all over again at the age I am now. I felt more
connected to the author in that way of one reading addict to another. I think
to tell a great story you have to have all the thoughts and emotions in
there. Self-education alone is such an
accomplishment! To teach yourself all the words in a dictionary is incredible.
It says a lot about education and how if you have real passion for it, you can
achieve it.
Monday, October 1, 2012
10/01/12 "How I learned to Program Computers"
Reading on “How I learned to program Computers”
The author, Feross, has a great way of pulling you into the story of
how he got started with Programming. I found the use of the print screen pictures a great add on
to the story. It helped keep it interesting and the flow going. I think after
reading this story I have a better idea of how my Education Narrative paper
should read. The story wasn’t “stiff”, as a lot of readings can be on
computers. (I should know, my job in the Navy was computers and computer
networking.) If programming was what I wanted to do, the author gave great
advice. Practice, practice, practice is the only way to go. You can take all
the classes you want, but you need to have a passion for what you do and do
everything you can to make your dream a reality. Nothing can hold you back
except for yourself. I need to think now on what kind of story I want to tell
for my Education Narrative. I have been taught by so many different people in
so many different ways, Civilian and Military alike. But after reading this, as
soon as I decide on what to focus on I know exactly how I want to write my
paper.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)