Thursday, October 11, 2012

The Differences and Similarities in the 3 Writing Styles of Rose, Franklin and X


Having now read and wrote about the 3 different writings for class I can pinpoint key differences and similarities between the narratives and styles of writing. Malcolm X’s and Mike Rose’s narratives seemed more informal in the way they were written. Benjamin Franklin’s narrative on the other hand seemed a lot more formal, but now looking at it again, I think his could be considered informal as well. He just had a different way of speaking back in that era, so it came off as a more formal type of writing.  In both Franklin and X’s narratives you could tell they both had a passion for what they were learning, while Rose’s narrative was more on his lack of passion for learning growing up due to his circumstance of being placed in the wrong class. While Malcolm’s narrative had a better flow, Rose and Franklin’s narrative had a lot of details, giving more of a back story to the point they were each trying to make.  Franklin’s tone seemed to stay on a more positive tone. Rose’s tone seemed to be more negative towards education. And X’s would bounce back in forth between the two with being positive about learning to read and negative about other parts of his story.

1 comment: