Thursday, October 25, 2012
Stand and Deliver Part 1
At first Mr. Escalante comes across as a very shy man who was put in way over his head. He quickly takes control of his class. The class seems to take to him very fast and starts participating and learning. He uses humor and terms the students can understand and relate to. Mr Escalante devotes so much of his time to his students, sacrifying his personnel life. I found it interesting that he gave up his high paying job with the computer company to become a teacher. I remember watching this movie in highschool and how boring I thought it was, I actually was not looking forward to being forced to watch this again. However, now as an adult i find the dynamic of the student/teacher relationship very interesting and am really enjoying the movie. One of the things asked after the first part of the video at the end of class was how Audre Lord's teachers compare to Mr. Escalante? Most of the students said things like "they are both stricked". After class was over i was thinking, there is no comparasion, they are polar opposites. Mr. Escalante takes the time to teach his students and he expects them to "rise to his expectation". Audre's teachers did not teach! They went by the set standard by the school and actually punished any student who tried to go above and beyond, therefore holding the child back instead of increasing their expectations as Mr. Escalante does.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I couldn't agree more with your analyzes of Mr. Escalante! Your comparison of Mr. Escalante and Audre Lorde's teacher is spot on. They are the complete bipolar opposites of each other. He teaches while Audre Lorde's teacher seemed not to care about the kids!
ReplyDeleteThats exactly what i was trying to get across, because i remember her asking how would you compare the two and thinking to myself, you can't, they are complete opposites.
ReplyDeleteExcellent observations, and I'm delighted that you've used specific details from the two texts (film and essay) to explain your ideas. Also great job of compare/contrast with the two types of teaching!
ReplyDelete