Wednesday, December 5, 2012

11/29 "Arizona bans Mexican American Studies Program"


“Arizona Bans Mexican American Studies Program”

By Deb Aronson

                After reading this article I can see that the program did help Mexican-American students. But how did it help any of the African American or Caucasian students? The problem I have is that I agree with part of the bill that was said that says it is illegal for courses or programs “to be designed primarily for pupils of a particular race or ethnic group”. All of the teachers interviewed for this article were Mexican American, what do the other teachers have to say about the subject? I think it is completely asinine to have an entire program dedicated to one race. Had the school had equally funded programs for each ethnic group to have those students be able to be catered to equally in education I would not have a problem with this idea. But you cannot designate school funds to only one ethnic group. If there was a European-American (Caucasian) designed program it would have been shut down immediately, and everyone would have been called racists. It is a sad fact in our society that everything has to be very “PC”.  I do not however agree with censorship. Every book that was not on the approved core reading list should have been made available to the students in the library and offered as an extra credit project. I went to a high school that was primarily Mexican and African American students. We never had anything like this, everyone was treated equally, had anyone been shown any extra favor it would have cause a riff in the school that probably would have resulted in a lot of in school fights. What does a white child know more about Beowulf than say any black, Asian, or Hispanic child? Nothing! It’s all mumbled words to us until it is taught and explained to us by our teacher.

No comments:

Post a Comment